US Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against Major RAM Manufacturers
A federal judge has allowed a class action lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron to proceed, rejecting claims that the companies did not coordinate production cuts.
- US District Judge Noël Wise denied a motion to dismiss the Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics lawsuit.
- The lawsuit alleges Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron conspired to create artificial shortages.
- The three manufacturers collectively hold over 91% of global DRAM revenue.
A federal judge has denied a motion to dismiss a class action lawsuit against major RAM manufacturers regarding alleged price-fixing. On 14 November 2026, US District Judge Noël Wise rejected a joint motion to dismiss the class action lawsuit, known as Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics.
The lawsuit was filed on 25 June in the Northern District of California. It consists of 17 plaintiffs, including 14 individuals and three small PC businesses from five states. The plaintiffs are represented by the antitrust firm Bathaee Dunne. They are suing as indirect purchasers under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, as well as various state antitrust and consumer protection laws.
The legal action alleges that Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron conspired to coordinate production cuts to create artificial shortages. According to the complaint, these three manufacturers collectively held more than 91% of global DRAM revenue. While the companies deny the allegations and claim they acted independently, the judge's decision allows the case to move forward. During the proceedings, Judge Noël Wise noted that the companies' arguments regarding monitoring pricing were comparable to hawks flying in formation.
Background and Market Context
The litigation arrives amidst a volatile market for Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM). The RAM market has faced a crisis throughout 2026 due to high demand from AI companies. This demand is driven by the migration to denser processes and the production of high-bandwidth memory (HBM). In June 2024, Micron reported that HBM3E consumes approximately three times the wafer supply of DDR5 for the same number of bits, a factor that influences global supply levels.
The financial impact of these supply dynamics has been reflected in contract pricing. Reports indicate that conventional DRAM contract prices saw a 171.8% increase in the year leading up to Q3 2025. This was followed by a 50% increase in Q4 2025 and a 95% increase in Q1 2026. A central dispute in the ongoing litigation is whether these price increases and shortages were caused by illegal coordination or by market demand and the AI boom.
The manufacturers have a history involving similar legal challenges. In 2005, Samsung and SK hynix pleaded guilty to a price-fixing conspiracy that occurred between 1998 and 2002. Following that case, Samsung was fined $300 million and SK hynix was fined $185 million. Micron avoided criminal prosecution during that 2005 case by acting as a whistleblower. Notably, a similar price-fixing lawsuit against these companies was dismissed in 2018 due to a lack of evidence.
Industry Landscape
The scale of the manufacturers involved is significant to the global tech economy. Beyond the current litigation, the industry is seeing massive shifts in supply agreements. In 2025, Samsung and OpenAI reached a manufacturing deal, with Samsung committing to supply roughly 40% of the world's DRAM production to the company.
As the case proceeds, the industry remains focused on how production is managed. DRAM production is heavily influenced by wafer starts and the shift toward more complex memory types. The outcome of this lawsuit could have significant implications for how the three largest players in the memory market manage production and pricing in the future.
Jika anda melihat kesilapan fakta dalam artikel ini, hubungi Pembetulan · Maklumatuntuk memberitahu kita. Kami akan mengesahkan, membetulkannya, dan menerbitkan pembetulan.
Macam mana artikel ini boleh berlaku?
Comments 0
Jadilah orang pertama yang boleh comment.
Artikel berkaitan
🎮Berita Utamasukan-e: Liga Utama, Jelajah & KejohananPanduan ini memberikan gambaran keseluruhan kejohanan e-sukan antarabangsa utama, memberi tumpuan kepada struktur dan hasil Kejohanan Dunia League of Legends 2026. Ia memperincikan lokasi hosting, pasukan yang mengambil bahagian, dan hasil kompetitif utama daripada acara itu.🎮Berita Utamasukan-esukan-e World Cup (EWC) ialah siri kejohanan e-sukan antarabangsa tahunan yang dikendalikan oleh Yayasan sukan-e, sebuah organisasi bukan untung. Ia dianggap sebagai acara e-sukan profesional terbesar di dunia dari segi jumlah kumpulan hadiah dan bilangan tajuk permainan yang diwakili, dengan lebih daripada AS $ 70 juta diberikan di seluruh kumpulan hadiah kejohanan individu, ganjaran untuk pasuka🎮Berita Utamasukan-e: Peraturan Rasmi, Pemarkahan, dan Panduan Rasmisukan-e, atau sukan elektronik, melibatkan pertandingan permainan video terancang yang dimainkan secara individu atau berkumpulan. Acara-acara ini telah berkembang daripada kejohanan arked awal kepada industri global yang menampilkan liga profesional dan kejohanan antarabangsa.🎮Berita Utamasukan-ePersekutuan sukan-e Antarabangsa (IESF) merupakan organisasi global yang berpangkalan di Korea Selatan yang misinya adalah untuk mempunyai sukan-e yang diiktiraf sebagai sukan yang sah. Menjelang Julai 2026, terdapat 152 negara anggota IESF.🎮Berita UtamaAntarabangsa (sukan-e)The International (TI) ialah kejohanan dunia e-sukan tahunan untuk permainan video lima-ke-lima Dota 2. Dihasilkan oleh pemaju permainan Valve, ia berfungsi sebagai acara kemuncak musim Dota 2 profesional dan kini mempunyai 16 pasukan.Pos-pos popular
sukan-e: Liga Utama, Jelajah & KejohananPanduan ini memberikan gambaran keseluruhan kejohanan e-sukan antarabangsa utama, memberi tumpuan kepada struktur dan hasil Kejohanan Dunia League of Legends 2026. Ia memperincikan lokasi hosting, pasukan yang mengambil bahagian, dan hasil kompetitif utama daripada acara itu.sukan-esukan-e World Cup (EWC) ialah siri kejohanan e-sukan antarabangsa tahunan yang dikendalikan oleh Yayasan sukan-e, sebuah organisasi bukan untung. Ia dianggap sebagai acara e-sukan profesional terbesar di dunia dari segi jumlah kumpulan hadiah dan bilangan tajuk permainan yang diwakili, dengan lebih daripada AS $ 70 juta diberikan di seluruh kumpulan hadiah kejohanan individu, ganjaran untuk pasukasukan-e: Peraturan Rasmi, Pemarkahan, dan Panduan Rasmisukan-e, atau sukan elektronik, melibatkan pertandingan permainan video terancang yang dimainkan secara individu atau berkumpulan. Acara-acara ini telah berkembang daripada kejohanan arked awal kepada industri global yang menampilkan liga profesional dan kejohanan antarabangsa.sukan-ePersekutuan sukan-e Antarabangsa (IESF) merupakan organisasi global yang berpangkalan di Korea Selatan yang misinya adalah untuk mempunyai sukan-e yang diiktiraf sebagai sukan yang sah. Menjelang Julai 2026, terdapat 152 negara anggota IESF.Antarabangsa (sukan-e)The International (TI) ialah kejohanan dunia e-sukan tahunan untuk permainan video lima-ke-lima Dota 2. Dihasilkan oleh pemaju permainan Valve, ia berfungsi sebagai acara kemuncak musim Dota 2 profesional dan kini mempunyai 16 pasukan.Langgan mendapatkan artikel baharu melalui e-mel. Berhenti melanggan bila-bila masa sahaja.